File №06 made the case against the prison and then stopped where Kropotkin stopped. Its last section listed what the argument could not answer. The first item was what happens when repair is refused, and what happens to the people a sentence leaves behind.
In the highlands and the Lacandon forest of Chiapas, communities have been answering those questions in practice for more than twenty years. The answers are written down. Their own authorities wrote them in the 2013 textbooks of the Zapatista escuelita, and a political scientist at the National Autonomous University of Mexico spent years recording cases zone by zone.
The system is not perfect, and this file does not present it as perfect. It works, people choose it, and it is built around one question the prison never asks: what is now owed to the people harmed?
This file does not claim the Zapatistas for any tradition. The communities that run this justice are Tseltal, Tsotsil, Ch’ol, Tojolabal, Zoque and Mam. They are not anarchists, and they have never asked to be adopted as anyone’s chapter. File №03 set the rule this series follows: an Indigenous legal practice is studied on its own terms, under its own authority, and not annexed to a European family tree.
A Zapatista authority is elected by an assembly, serves a term, and hands over. Terms ran three years. Even inside that term, nobody held the office continuously.
The rotation is the point. An office nobody holds for long is hard to turn into a career, a fortune or a following. The rule behind it has a name everyone in the region knows, mandar obedeciendo, to lead by obeying. The 2003 communiqué that founded the Juntas put it as an instruction: “whoever leads must lead by obeying.”
The escuelita textbooks list seven principles that every authority is held to:
- Serve, and not serve yourself.
- Represent, and not replace.
- Build, and not destroy.
- Obey, and not command.
- Propose, and not impose.
- Convince, and not defeat.
- Go down, and not up.
For justice, this matters in a specific way. The person hearing your case is a neighbour on a short shift who will be an ordinary member of the assembly again soon. They are not a career judge, and they answer to the same people you do.
The reason they gave is the reason any federation should study. On 15 November 2023, Subcomandante Insurgente Moisés wrote: “The main problem is the damn pyramid.” Over two decades the Juntas had drifted away from the villages they served, and “the pyramid separated the authorities from the towns.” Outgoing authorities had not trained successors. Outside organisations had learned to route their projects through the top.
The system noticed it was centralising, said so in public, and moved authority back down to the village assembly.The Federation · on the 2023 restructuring
It happened under pressure. The same communiqués describe towns across the region in the hands of drug cartels, and the caracoles, the regional centres, were closed to outsiders until further notice. File №09 argued that federation is a protocol, a set of rules for how authority moves. This is what changing the protocol looks like when the people running it do it themselves.
Ask the authorities of the Morelia zone what happens to someone who breaks the rules, and they answer in one sentence that excludes both instruments a Mexican court would reach for:
“They have to do collective work. If it happened in the village, they work in the village. We are not charging them money, and we are not putting them in jail.”
“Tiene que hacer trabajos colectivos, si es en el pueblo tiene que trabajar en el pueblo, no le estamos cobrando dinero ni tampoco lo estamos metiendo en la cárcel.”
The sanction rises with repetition. The same zone published its ladder for drunkenness, which is banned in Zapatista communities:
- 1stA warning.
- 2ndFive days of work for the community.
- 3rdTen days of work for the municipality.
- 4thThe case goes up to the caracol, the regional centre.
The process starts with listening. In her study of the Selva Tzeltal zone, Paulina Fernández Christlieb describes a justice built on hearing both parties until they reach an agreement, without anyone paying anything. Her reviewer summed up the book's finding: this justice “is not a commodity; it is not bought, it is not sold.”
The word repair is literal. The labour goes back into the place the harm was done, with the offender working alongside the people they wronged. They do not sit in a building far away from everyone involved.
The hardest case is the one Kropotkin never reached. On 7 August 2002 a man named José López Santiz was killed in Altamirano. Thirteen days later, La Jornada reported what a Zapatista leader told the governor of Chiapas:
“Under our Zapatista law, whoever kills has to support the widow, and if he has property, half of it is hers. We Zapatistas are not going to kill them. We are going to do justice.”
“En nuestra ley zapatista el que asesina tiene que mantener a la viuda, y si tiene bienes la mitad es para ella.”
Five years later, at a gathering in the Morelia caracol on 24 July 2007, the Selva Tzeltal zone gave the same rule in its own report. A person convicted of homicide is made responsible for caring for the orphaned family until they can support themselves. If he owns property, half of it is collected and placed in the hands of the bereaved.
In a household that lives on maize, supporting a family means working its field. That is the milpa in the panel.
The Prisons file counted what a convict's family earned while he was inside: under one franc fifty a day, for a woman and her children who were never convicted of anything. The Zapatista rule makes the same calculation and comes out the other way. It does not ask what the killer deserves. It asks who is now going without, and makes him the answer.
The most revealing fact about this system is who else uses it. In the San Andrés zone, the autonomous council told the escuelita that members of all three national parties, the PRI, the PAN and the PRD, came to them to settle their problems. These are people who belong to the government's side of the conflict.
It cost the council money it did not have, so the authorities tried sending them back to the state:
Fernández Christlieb found the same thing in the Selva Tzeltal zone. Non-Zapatista Indigenous people who suffered the injustice of the official system were among those who sought out this justice most. They included members of organisations openly opposed to the EZLN, because the official channels only meant spending money without resolving anything. In 2016, Luis Hernández Navarro wrote in La Jornada that it was sought “not only by the rebels, but also, surprisingly, by the non-Zapatistas.”
No one is conscripted into this court. The people who come to it have a state court available and choose not to use it.
“Faster, cheaper, less corrupt” could sound like a slogan. Mexico's statistics agency measures the alternative every year. Its national victimisation survey, published in September 2026 and covering 2025, counted 33.8 million crimes.
The most common reason people gave for not reporting a crime was not fear. It was that reporting is a waste of time, cited by 35.8 per cent. Distrust of the authorities was cited by 13.0 per cent.
Set the two systems side by side. One takes your case only after the trip, the paperwork and the fees, and then resolves about one crime in a hundred. The other is held in your own village, by a neighbour who will be back in the assembly next month, and it costs nothing. People are not choosing an ideology here. They are choosing the court that solves the problem.
A system can only be learned from if its limits are stated as plainly as its successes. These are on the record, most of them in the Zapatistas’ own words.
Short detention exists
“No jail” is the rule for most offences, but it is not absolute. In their own account of domestic violence, Zapatista women report that men have been punished “with up to a week in jail,” alongside counselling. The honest summary is that detention is short and rare, not that it never happens.
The gravest cases can still cross to the state
Asked about murder, a Morelia authority said they worked with a human rights centre and that the offender “has to serve his sentence.” In April 2025, state forces arrested two Zapatistas for a kidnapping and killing. The autonomous authorities ran their own investigation, detained two other men who confessed and led them to the body, and handed those men to the government through a human rights centre. The two Zapatistas were released. This is the EZLN’s account, reported in La Jornada. The case shows the system working, and it also shows that it does not try to hold everything itself.
The women’s law is not fully kept, by the women’s own account
The Revolutionary Women’s Law, made public with the 1994 uprising, says in its eighth article that no woman may be beaten or mistreated. The women who report on it say plainly that this article “has not been fully complied with.” Women in the Altos zone wrote a ban on alcohol into their own proposed expansion of the law, “because we are the ones who suffer the blows.”
The structure failed, and they had to say so
The 2023 dissolution is a self-criticism: the pyramid, the distance from the villages, no successors trained, and authorities sanctioned for poor administration. A system that can admit this in public is healthier than one that cannot. It also means the justice described in the 2013 textbooks has since been reorganised, and how cases are handled under the new local governments has not yet been documented in detail.
It runs under siege, and without legal recognition
Zapatista communities have faced repeated armed attacks from neighbouring organisations: burned fields and gunfire at Moisés Gandhi in 2019, 2021 and 2023. Cartels now control the region’s towns, and the caracoles are closed to outsiders. Mexican law does not recognise community labour as a substitute for prison. All of this justice operates with no state backing at all.
Kropotkin's case against the prison was that it fails at its own purpose. The Zapatista practice suggests a sharper test, one that can be applied to any court, sentence or program in any country.
If the answer is the state, the sentence can be served in full while the people harmed are left exactly where the harm left them. If the answer is the people harmed, the sentence is not finished until they have been made whole, as far as anyone can make them whole.
Rotation keeps the judge accountable to the assembly. Repair puts the offender's labour back where the harm was done. The widow's rule turns a sentence into support. The non-Zapatista at the door keeps the system honest, because he is free to leave and he doesn't. None of this depends on believing anything about human nature. It depends on deciding, before the verdict, who the verdict is for.
Justice that owes something to the people harmed.
